Road taxesPosted on April 10th, 2011 7 comments
From time to time, we will see a recurring theme to the effect of “bicyclists don’t pay gas tax so they don’t deserve to use the road”. (for a good roundup of this and other similar issues see bicycledriving.org) There are certain elements of truth to this — bicyclists don’t purchase gas, it’s true. And there’s also an implication that motorist are “paying their way”, but that’s just not true. Gas taxes (and other direct taxes on automobiles) nowhere near cover the costs of building, maintaining, and operating roads. And that’s not to mention the (much larger) costs associated with death/mayhem and pollution impacts on human health and the environment. And none of that is to mention other more intangible costs like defending sea lanes worldwide; and propping up unsavory regimes so that oil can continue to flow freely.
Funding for local roads (the roads that both cyclists and motorists use) are paid for heavily through state and local tax general funds — not user fess like gasoline taxes. Cyclists are paying their way, just like everybody else.
Most/much of the direct user fees that motorists pay do go to fund freeways (limited access highways). These roads are used exclusively (with minor exceptions) by motorists — and yet even then the fees are not high enough, and have to be supplemented from other sources, like general sales taxes.
Specifics vary depending on location but the general theme is similar throughout the US.
What follows are specifics as we do things here in Arizona, and specifically Maricopa County and the Phoenix Metro area.
Arizona levies two taxes directly upon motorists and the proceeds are termed the “HURF” (Highway User’s something Fund). The two souces are; motor fuel taxes, and VLT (Vehicle License Tax, a fee paid yearly based on the value of a motor vehicle).
Because the rate on gasoline is levied per gallon, 18.5 cents per gallon, and hasn’t changed since 199?, the amounts available to the HURF have been dwindling.
usgovernmentspending.com has some good charts of, e.g. ARizona state spending broken down in categories like education, police, transportation, etc.
Freeway Sales Tax
Maricopa county levies a 0.25% (check that) 20-year SALES tax to build freeways. First approved in 1985, it was set to expire in 2005 but extended for another 20 years by “Proposition 400″. The split was more favorable to public transit, but still heavily favors freeway spending. The most vociferous opposition came from those who specifically thought that not enough of the money would be used for freeways, and in particular hated that any monies would be spent on light-rail. See e.g. Prop. 400 foe wants to stop light rail., Arizona Republic, Sept 23, 2004.
I note that bicyclists do not ride bikes on freeways (in fact, bicycles are banned from freeways in the metro area).
So, the freeway sales tax is just another externality of automobility — drivers not paying their way.
Background on Federal Tax
The federal levy on fuel is much the same story — it is based solely on a per-gallon charge of 18.4 cents per gallon gasoline THAT HASN’T GONE UP SINCE !993! Of course, the price level has gone up a lot since then, so the amount of real dollars keeps falling. If 18.4 was the “right” amount in 1993, the rate should be raised to ~ 28 cents/gal (2011 dollars). These missing dollars of course still get spent, replace from other sources like general funds; funds that everybody pays, not just drivers.
A minority of the fuel tax funds (about 15%) is spent on mass transit, and 0.1 cents of it is spent on cleanup for leaking underground fuel storage tanks.
Historical gasoline fuel tax rates from Table 1 CRS report:
Rate of Tax in cents per gallon Period to Which Applicable 1.0 June 21, 1932, to June 16, 1933 1.5 June 17, 1933, to December 31, 1933 1.0 January 1, 1934, to June 30, 1940 1.5 July 1, 1940, to October 31, 1951 2.0 November 1, 1951, to June 30, 1956 3.0 July 1, 1956, to September 30, 1959 4.0 October 1, 1959, to March 31, 1983 9.0 April 1, 1983, to December 31, 1986 9.1 January 1, 1987, to August 31, 1990 (a) 9.0 September 1, 1990, to November 30, 1990 14.1 December 1, 1990 , to September 30, 1993 18.4 October 1, 1993, to December 31, 1995 (b) 18.3 January 1, 1996 (c), to September 30, 1997 18.4 October 1, 1997 (d), to March 31, 2005
There are also some excise taxes aimed at heavy trucks — based on the obvious theory that heavier vehicles cause more wear and tear on roads and bridges.
2 Trackbacks / Pingbacks
[...] on fuel, nor do they pay other use taxes, like Arizona’s VLT (Vehicle License Tax). More on Road Taxes in [...]
[...] about fuel and other specific use taxes (like the VLT… for more, see Road Taxes)? They’re simply not enough. Automobility does not generate enough tax revenue to sustain [...]
Leave a reply